Videos by ComicBook.com
Yet for all its brilliance, some fans have pointed out how the episode’s logic doesn’t hold up under examination. “The Measure of a Man” is beloved for its courtroom drama appeal, but it’s also plagued with canon question marks. The episode asks whether Lt. Commander Data is a sentient being with rights, but by this point, Data has been a decorated Starfleet officer for over two decades. He’s the second officer on the flagship of the Federation. So, shouldn’t someone have decided this question a long time ago?
The Data Dilemma That The Next Generation Fans Are Still Debating
The episode spirals out from a seemingly innocuous line. As he’s leaving the bridge, an admiral turns to Picard and says, “Commander Maddox will be working on your android, by the way. See to it.” The line reframes Commander Data as property, however this notion seems impossible given what TNG had already established up to that point. Data had graduated from Starfleet Academy, served for 25 years, and risen to command rank. That journey would have required numerous reviews, promotions, and psychological evaluations. Somewhere in all that, someone would have legally recognized his personhood, or at least noticed that Starfleet’s most famous android wasn’t standard issue equipment.
The episode compounds the problem with Maddox’s backstory. Data tells Picard that Maddox was on the panel that reviewed his Starfleet application and was the only one to vote “no” on the grounds that Data isn’t sentient. But this line admits that the rest of the board voted “yes,” acknowledging Data as a sentient being capable of entering Starfleet. In other words, Starfleet had actually already decided this decades ago, and yet the episode revolves aroun the Federation re-litigating.
The court treats Data’s rights like an open question, despite the fact that he’s a high-ranking officer entrusted with command decisions and the lives of hundreds. Viewers have also pointed out that no one in Starfleet seems to have heard of him, which makes little sense given that he’s the first and only android to ever wear the uniform. If this were real, Data would be a Federation celebrity. When Riker disables Data in court to prove he can be turned off, the gallery gasps, but this isn’t really a shocking revelation, is it? Any biological life form can be rendered unconscious or incapacitated.
