Videos by ComicBook.com
In an interview with Triple J (via Entertainment Weekly), Crowe lobbied a pointed critique at Gladiator II, explaining why he felt the sequel fell short of its predecessor. “I think the recent sequel that we don’t have to name out loud is a really unfortunate example of even the people in that engine room not actually understanding what made the first one special,” Crowe said. “It wasn’t the pomp, it wasn’t the circumstance, it wasn’t the action — it was the moral core.”
He continued, “There was a daily fight on that set — it was a daily fight to keep that moral core of the character. The amount of times they suggested sex scenes and stuff like that for Maximus, it’s like, you’re taking away his power. What are you talking about? So you’re saying that at the same time [that] he had this relationship with his wife, he was f—ing this other girl? What are you talking about? It’s crazy.”
Russell Crowe Is Right About Gladiator II
To be fair, the twist about Lucius’ parentage doesn’t come entirely out of nowhere. The original Gladiator alludes to a romantic history between Maximus and Lucilla. Through their exchanges, it’s clear they had a previous relationship with each other before setting out on separate paths. The intention behind the reveal in Gladiator II was most likely to build on that specific plot point, adding an extra layer to Maximus’ dynamic with not just Lucilla but also Lucius. In the first Gladiator, Maximus develops a strong bond with the boy, so some could read Gladiator II as a way to deepen that connection. Lucius spends the sequel following his father’s footsteps.
Still, Gladiator fans would be forgiven if they felt this didn’t all add up. Early on in Gladiator, Lucilla mentions that Lucious is nearly 8 years old, and Maximus notes that his own son is the same age. The obvious takeaway there is that Maximus was having an affair with Lucilla while he was married and starting a family with his wife. That’s an action that goes against the strong “moral core” that Crowe alludes to in his comments, painting the character of Maximus in a different light. Crowe understood what made Maximus so special; he’s a noble, humble leader who is greatly committed to those closest to him. Maximus’ entire motivation in the first film is avenging his murdered wife and son, so the fact that he fathered a child with another woman undercuts that a bit.
