Every Ghostface Reveal in Scream, Ranked

Videos by ComicBook.com

We really are just looking at the moment when the audience realizes that a character is a killer. What happens after that (e.g. their death) didn’t factor in nor did their overall memorability as a killer. For instance, Scream 4‘s Jill Roberts is one of the best Ghostface killers. Her motive is perfectly morbid, the scene where she beats herself up couldn’t be more fun, and Emma Roberts’ performance is exactly what the character needed. But those factors didn’t enter the conversation of where she ranked.

15) Marco

image courtesy of paramount pictures

Scream 7‘s main Ghostface reveal sequence kicks off with a reference to Steve Orth’s being tied up in the original film as if that moment would be important to Sidney, even though she wasn’t present for that in 1996. The tied-up thing was already done way better in Scream 4, so this is a very standard character unmasking themself scene. Worse yet, it holds no power considering we saw Marco exactly once before he does so.

14) Karl Gibbs

image courtesy of paramount pictures

Karl Gibbs’ attack on the Prescott-Evans house is one of Scream 7‘s stronger set pieces, but its end result lands with a bit of a thud. He stumbles back into the street after being overpowered by Sidney, Mark, and Tatum, and, because it’s happened in 10,000 movies, we’re just waiting for him to get hit by a vehicle. He does, and then he’s unmasked. And, gasp, it’s a guy we saw once in Sidney’s cafe who was blatantly creepy and fully expected to be a killer. It’s a Chekov’s Gun thing. Why show him being creepy unless he’s going to be either a victim or a Ghostface?

13) Ethan

image courtesy of paramount pictures

We’ve gone up a quality notch here, but it’s a tip toe, not a leap. Ethan Landry is creepy the entire time he’s onscreen in Scream VI. He’s conveniently missing while Quinn (who ends up being his sister) is “attacked” for instance. However, points go to the reveal for having the subway scene with him and Mindy. At least for a second we’re thrown off his scent. But the scene still raises the question of how he went with Mindy to the hospital then left and came to the theater. Furthermore, how did Mindy, upon showing up, know he was one of the killers? Because she said so. Did he try to get her at the hospital? It’s a Ghostface reveal that is mostly memorable for the questions it raises, and they’re unanswered ones.

12) Jessica

image courtesy of paramount pictures

Throughout Scream 7, fans are led to believe Stu Macher is back. Scarred and killing. Thankfully, he’s not. More fans were hoping the sequel wasn’t going that direction than there were those hoping it was. Instead, we get Sidney’s next-door neighbor, Jessica. We’ve gotten to know her more than Karl or Marco, but still not enough for the reveal to really matter. Then she lists her three meh motives. Extra credit for the fact she killed her own son, though. That’s a character detail that builds up her fear factor.

11) Quinn

image courtesy of paramount pictures

Consider Quinn Bailey’s reveal basically tied with the next entry. There’s one element to it that really works and one that really does not. The one that works is that the audience is led to believe Quinn is dead, and that’s done effectively. As for the part that doesn’t, it’s the fact that the other characters assume it’s Mindy Meeks-Martin. But the audience knows it’s not Mindy. For one, we just saw her get stabbed on the subway. And, even if we hadn’t, we wouldn’t have bought it. Just by the process of elimination, it was obvious it was Quinn as soon as Ethan’s mask was already off.

10) Detective Bailey

image courtesy of paramount pictures

Scream VI wants us to believe that Kirby Reed is the killer because Detective Wayne Bailey wants the protagonists to believe the same. It doesn’t quite work because we as the audience know and trust Kirby more than him, but there were worse directions to go. We also like Dermot Mulroney’s little smile and shrug as he says, “Of course it’s me.”

9) Jill

image courtesy of dimension films

Again, Jill is a top-tier Ghostface, but she doesn’t have the best reveal of her film. It’s a shock to Sidney (and 2011 theatergoers) when she unmasks herself, but it’s still a pretty standard self-unmasking. However, her monologue revelation about how it was she who killed her mother was an effectively sick addition.

8) Roman Bridger

image courtesy of dimension films

Like the film as a whole, the Ghostface reveal of Roman Bridger in Scream 3 isn’t quite as good as those that came before him. The big issue is that it’s so obvious it’s Roman. Gale goes downstairs, finds him in a fake casket, checks for a pulse, and doesn’t find one. When he’s the only character who gets a fully off-screen death and it’s in the middle of the third act, it’s clear that’s your killer. However, the location of John Milton’s screening room is a great stage for the reveal and the home movies being displayed help build up the scene’s importance.

7) Stu Macher

image courtesy of dimension films

Back in 1996, the moment when Stu Macher holds the voice changer to his mouth and says, “Surprise Sidney!” was an important one in horror history. We didn’t have just one killer, but two. And, thanks to Matthew Lillard’s joyous line delivery, we see the same happy-go-lucky character we’ve grown to find humorous and likable using that personality in a far more sinister way.

6) Mrs. Loomis

image courtesy of dimension films

Scream 2 notoriously had its script leak, and in that script both Derek and Hallie were the killers. Suffice to say, the final product’s killers are much better. Mrs. Loomis’ presence is far more believable. After all, we already learned in the original film that her ex-husband’s cheating on her rattled her cage, so why not have her come back when she learns her child was shot in the head? Granted, the scenes with her annoying Gale throughout the movie (under the name Debbie Salt) are a bit of a tell that she’s not who she’s claiming to be, because why else would she get so much screentime, but it still works, primarily because Debbie is so off the audience sees her as a red herring character. It just so happens this herring ends up being the real thing.

5) Richie Kirsch

image courtesy of paramount pictures

Like Scream 4, the following film occasionally aims to replicate the original film’s story beats. And, even more than in Scream 4, it succeeds in doing so. This is especially true of the Richie is Ghostface reveal. It’s a pseudo-replication of the Billy Loomis reveal, but here we expect him even less. But, like Billy, he stumbles down the stairs and reveals himself, this time by pulling out a knife and stabbing Sam Carpenter in the side. It works, primarily because it goes from him shrieking “Oh, s**t! It’s Ghostface!” upstairs to the attack so quickly, not to mention the fact that Jack Quaid is such a likable on-screen presence.

4) Amber Freeman

image courtesy of paramount pictures

Richie orchestrated the events of Scream (2022), but Amber was the more memorable Ghostface, and she got more kills under her belt. Not to mention, her reveal is also just a hair above Richie’s. It really does come out of nowhere when she shoots a screaming Liv in the head, turning to most of the living protagonists with the line “Welcome to act three” bleeding through a big smile.

3) Mickey Altieri

Mickey Altieri’s Ghostface reveal is another case of the surroundings playing a role in the overall scene’s impact. Scream 7 makes great use of a school theater but Scream 2 still has it beat. The music blares from within the building as Sidney runs back to the campus, she enters, Derek drops down, covered in marker drawings and tied up to a big prop cross, and the music stops. Then we hear the Ghostface voice, which shuts off and is replaced by Timothy Olyphant’s unmistakable voice asking Sidney, “Don’t ya know history repeats itself?” Cue the monologue that shows how Mickey is even more detached from reality than Billy and Stu.

2) Charlie Walker

As mentioned, Scream 7 tries to replicate the whole Steven Orth departure scene, but it feels like blatant fan service. Scream 4 does it in a way that fits in with the film’s theme of trying to replicate the original. And it really, really works. First off, Kirby on the phone with Ghostface (Jill) rattling off every then-modern horror remake to try and save Charlie is one of the best moments of desperation in the franchise. Her heart is an altruistic one and, when she feels as though she’s succeeded, that altruism is rewarded with a knife to the gut by the one she was trying to save. It was devastating in theaters and still works like a charm today.

1) Billy Loomis

Billy Loomis is so charming throughout Scream it’s a gut punch to learn he’s actually vicious. Quite often he seems to genuinely care for Sidney, but it’s all an act, and that is revealed with a turn in both the literal and narrative sense. And, as he turns around, he utters one of the most classic lines in horror cinema and pulls a trigger. “We all go a little mad sometimes.”

Which is your favorite Ghostface reveal? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!