6 Darkest PlayStation 1 Games of All Time, Ranked

Videos by ComicBook.com

Here are the six darkest games on the original PlayStation. Keep in mind, this isn’t strictly about scare factor. We’re looking for games that pushed the boundaries for a medium that had previously been seen as something for children.

6) Shadow Man

Image courtesy of Acclaim

Shadow Man was originally a comic book from Valiant Comics, but the property was purchased by Acclaim. They then turned around and switched main characters, putting the series in the hands of the legendary Garth Ennis. Plus, they put out an excellent game in 1999 that was surprisingly difficult and predictably grim.

The game starts with Jack the Ripper realising that his ritualistic murders are not enough to earn the mystical power he seeks. Then, he meets a being named Legion, who has him build an asylum for like-minded killers. It only gets wilder from there, as protagonist Michael LeRoi must delve into the land of the dead to take down the asylum.

5) OverBlood

OverBlood isn’t a great game by survival horror standards. The gameplay is bland, and there are far too many instances of the player wandering through the halls searching for the next puzzle to solve. That’s relatively common among games that were maybe a bit too ambitious for the time.

See, OverBlood was one of the first survival horror games to use a fully 3D world. Unlike Resident Evil, with its pre-rendered backgrounds, OverBlood was trying to move things forward. It didn’t quite succeed, but OverBlood‘s journey through a grotesque sci-fi world is gripping. There aren’t many spooky monsters that’ll strike fear into your heart, but some of the implications of what’s happening in that Arctic base are just as chilling.

4) Resident Evil 3: Nemesis

The third Resident Evil game earns its spot on this list because of the titular villain. Every Resident Evil game is scary, and most of them veer toward disturbing when you start to explore exactly what’s going on behind the scenes.

However, Nemesis takes that to a new level. Not only is this creature stalking you through the city, sending your heart rate through the roof every time it appears, but it’s also jarring to see Nemesis ripping through your former team members. And despite Nemesis being such a compelling villain, Nikolai Zinoviev might actually be the scariest person you’ll come across in Jill Valentine’s adventure. Oh, and don’t forget the game ends with Raccoon City being vaporized. It’s not exactly a happy ending.

3) Nightmare Creatures

Nightmare Creatures is, like a few other games on this list, not exactly the smoothest-playing game you’ll ever encounter. Granted, the PlayStation version is the best of its ports, but even there, the controls leave something to be desired, and the camera is best described as wonky.

However, for this list, we don’t care about that. If you’re looking for a spooky atmosphere, it doesn’t get much better on the PlayStation. Nightmare Creatures involves a devil-worshipping cult that is trying to take over London with malevolent experimentation. That culminates in a man loosely based on real-life occultist Aleister Crowley unleashing grotesque monsters on the city. As you can imagine, Nightmare Creatures only ups the ante from there.

2) Echo Night

You might be surprised to learn that FromSoftware put out a first-person horror adventure game on the original PlayStation. If that’s the case, I’m here to let you know there are four Echo Night games, with two launching on the PS1, one on the PS2, and one on the PSP. So, if you’re looking to dig into FromSoft’s roots, you have several games from this series to play.

Echo Night sees the player exploring their father’s house while learning about the mysterious disappearance of a ship called the Orpheus. In fact, you’ll end up on the ship yourself, trying to save the ghosts who were lost when it disappeared. Unfortunately, some of those ghosts are hostile, and there’s also a serial killer who might be possessed to deal with. It’s a boat trip you won’t forget.

1) Silent Hill

The original Silent Hill doesn’t get the love of the second entry, but that doesn’t make Harry Mason’s journey any less compelling. Plus, Silent Hill 2 launched on the PlayStation 2, so we don’t have to worry about it for this list. The first Silent Hill is obviously Konami’s take on the Resident Evil formula, but it largely trades monster-fighting action for psychological horror.

Don’t get me wrong, there are jump scares, but Silent Hill is much more about building an oppressive atmosphere that slowly constricts the players into fear. It’s deeply unsettling and will leave you thinking about the events you play through long after you roll credits. Simply put, Silent Hill is the kind of game that might give you nightmares for years if you don’t come in prepared.

What do you think? Leave a comment below and join the conversation now in the ComicBook Forum!